There are, after four years, six investigations and two congressional hearings, still a host of unanswered questions about how Pat was killed. Boots on the Ground is yet another attempt by Mary Tillman and her very private family to force the spotlight upon his case--and to their discomfort, put the spotlight on themselves.
Mary Tillman and the Tillman family are a very true reflection about where we are as a country and where we are as a people desperate to end this war. They are furious and disillusioned, like so many of us. They are also isolated and dislocated from the kind of movement that could bring the troops home...like so many of us.
I want to ask Mary Tillman about all of this. I also want to ask Mary Tillman why she believes this government chose to smother Tillman's death in propaganda and how the story could have careened so recklessly from killed in action to a friendly-fire death, shot at long range in the chest, to the truth--bullets at close range in the forehead. I want to ask her what she thinks of a president who, armed with the facts, would lie over Pat's dead body. I want to know if she believes George W. Bush belongs in prison.
But I also want to ask Mary Tillman about the person her son was, and the person her son was becoming: the Pat Tillman moving against the war in Iraq; the Pat Tillman who was a voracious reader, turning his attention to critics of empire like Noam Chomsky; the Pat Tillman whose journal and personal effects were burned and destroyed immediately following his death.
This is a Pat Tillman who deserves to be heard.
And I also feel a need to ask Mary Tillman about their strategies seeking justice. The Tillmans have taken great pains to pursue the truth alone, not enlisting organizations like Iraq Veterans Against War or United for Peace and Justice. They have relied on people like Gen. Wesley Clark or Sen. John McCain (who spoke at Pat's funeral) to be vigilant on their behalf. I want to ask Mary Tillman if she fears that John McCain would not be an honest truth seeker given his unconditional support for the war. I want to ask her what her other son Kevin, who enlisted in the Army Rangers alongside Pat, thinks of Senator McCain.
Remember, it was before the 2006 mid-term elections that Kevin released a scathing statement called "After Pat's Birthday," which read in part,
Somehow those afraid to fight an illegal invasion decades ago are allowed to send soldiers to die for an illegal invasion they started.
Somehow faking character, virtue and strength is tolerated.
Somehow profiting from tragedy and horror is tolerated.
Somehow the death of tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of people is tolerated.
Somehow subversion of the Bill of Rights and The Constitution is tolerated.
Somehow suspension of Habeas Corpus is supposed to keep this country safe.
Somehow torture is tolerated.
Somehow lying is tolerated.
Somehow reason is being discarded for faith, dogma, and nonsense.
Somehow American leadership managed to create a more dangerous world.
Somehow a narrative is more important than reality.
Somehow America has become a country that projects everything that it is not and condemns everything that it is. Somehow the most reasonable, trusted and respected country in the world has become one of the most irrational, belligerent, feared, and distrusted countries in the world.
Somehow being politically informed, diligent, and skeptical has been replaced by apathy through active ignorance. Somehow the same incompetent, narcissistic, virtueless, vacuous, malicious criminals are still in charge of this country.
Somehow this is tolerated.
The Tillman family has been transformed by tragedy. They are like so many people in this country that saw their trust in an administration abused, and their loved ones sacrificed by "narcissistic, virtueless, vacuous, malicious criminals." I want to ask Mary Tillman about how you even begin to rebuild yourself, your family and your sense of self when it all gets ripped away. And at long last, I want to ask her, as a fellow parent, where in the world she gets the strength.
On what McCain would do, one only has to recall the Kerry Committee hearings on MIAs/Pows.
McCain himself a former prisoner let them down
by voting against subpeonas and in general
acting to allow a full investigation (as did Kerry).
The Tillman's have come close to accusing the
government of murdering their son. Certainly it
seems that an enormous amount of attention was being paid to Pat Tillman's daily activities up to the level of Rumsfeld. It was if they were
waiting for something to happen so they could
exploit it, which is exactly what they did. And did
immediately. Maybe it was "just in case he gets
killed" maybe not.
Hi Dave Z,
I listened to the Mary Tillman interview this morning with Amy Goodman on DemocracyNow. She did not mention any of the candidates who are running for POTUSA as having any commentary on Pat's execution by friendly fire. That, alone, says a lot. She has the potential of engaging a huge audience and getting these politicians to actually say something substantive on the corruption of the U.S. military and administration, and she is missing it.
I want to know what the NFL and its players have to say about one of their own being murdered in their name, and then lied to about the circumstances. I liked Mary's comment regarding the honor of dying for one's country being authentic only if killed by the enemy. She made the analogy of being killed by a car not being any less honorable than being in the war zone. My paraphrase. Of course, being in the war zone is not honorable when one is there for lies and corporate profits, dead or alive.
One point that is not made is that any organization whose strategy includes the killing and maiming of other human beings, whether "innocent" civilians or combatants, is not to be trusted to tell the truth, ever. I'd love to see you make that point. We don't expect killers to tell the truth on the witness stand in a court trial; why would we expect them to tell the truth in this incident?
I thought at one point there was a Mr. Tillman/father in this story. Is he out of the picture?
What are your comments?
Having retired from the US Navy in the mid 70's, I had to watch the beginnings of this fundie movement where they had their best and brightest enlist in the military and it's Officer Corps. They made no secret what they were up to in the early 70's and do not to this day. The leading officers in all branches seem to be linked through prayer meetings and seminars, etc., I walked into a classified space on a guided missile destroyer to do some work and found about 15 men of the ships company holding a religious meeting. These were from various rates/ratings and only 2 of them were authorized to be in the space. I immediately had the space sealed and had the master at arms and the Officer Of The Day called. This in turn caused a firestorm that was not only ugly and mean, but life threatening. These people are out to gain control of the Armed Forces, you already have seen what they have done to the government, no matter which branch.. Religion is in control of the various offices and until that genie is put back in it's bottle, we're in a heap of hurt.
Pat Tillman was killed to keep him quiet, and to destroy all the evidence that he had been able to gather. He was a known atheist, and as such wasn't deserving to live, according to the beliefs of the fundie reich wing out there.
I only hope that when January rolls around, President Obama will have all his Justice Dept. ducks in a row, and we can get to the bottom of this and many other overflowing barrels of republican dung.
Damn! How I hate these bastards who destroyed the country of my birth!
Thank you Dave! I am a high school history teacher teaching the Iraq War. You have expressed, in the last few paragraphs of your essay, all of my frustrations in dealing with these important issues. Being called a communist (who does that anymore?) by other teachers, teenagers with a video-game blood-lust... Unfortunately, I do not have faith that America will be able to pull itself out of its descent. I do however, continue to instill in the kids a love for what this country should and could be. Thank you so much for shining an utterly fascinating and unique light on the world of sports; I wait anxiously for the new book!!
I'd be interested in what she'd like me and anyone else who's listening to do. Ask her what Steve Bzomowski, someone who feels heartbroken for her and sad and angry at the country for what it's doing and what's it's become, can do. Not just about Pat Tillman but about the whole immoral, virtueless lot of them who could lie, pretend, threaten, placate, so thoroughly ruin what was once a place of hope and promise.
Seems to me, there are issues and events and moments that in their telling and re-telling, in their unravelling toward the truth, can crystallize for people what the problems are and where solutions lie: the Pat Tillman story, the Pat Tillman tragedy, is one of them.
I with maheanuu on this one: here's to praying that Obama takes 'em on and knows that not only do we have his back, but that we're with him. Bottom line: they're killing us and stealing our money. Are they not?
Good luck.
Thank you, Mr. Zirin. Sincere condolences to the Tillman family. Mary Tillman is doing what she must do, in the best way she knows how. As is Cindy Sheehan. We all handle overwhelming grief in different ways. What noble cause, Sheehan asks? Indeed.
Six investigations at least. I've heard the number seven. It's a coverup and one must ask why and who is being protected? Where is Bush's totally politicized Department of Justice? Why is there no murder investigation?
Maheanuu has hit the nail on the head. How long will it take to turn it around? Maybe never, but with an engaged populace it's possible, but it will take two generations.
I don't begrudge people their religious beliefs but they have no place in government.
Dave,
Thanks for sending your articles to me. I really appreciate and admire your work. I feel tremendously for the Tillman family. However, I lost respect for Pat when he turned his relative fame into hero worship by enlisting in the army. He was immediately (and I'm sure with his approval) portrayed around the country as a true warrior, fighting to save Western democracy--the oldest lie in the history of Western combat. Worse still, he was a recruiter's dream. Not knowing him, I immediately assumed he was either a dumb, country redneck in love with high-powered guns, or he was a willing propaganda tool--the guy who would look the part of the football player-turned-patriot-hero, but who would, in reality, reside in Baghdad's Green Zone, working with the most shameless of Hollywood producers.
To hear that he had changed his mind, or that he was even reading Chomsky, is heartwarming. I hope his family, with your help, can get his story out there in the mainstream. And I hope that the process of learning the truth will make them stronger in the years to come. Their work in this regard would be a tribute to Pat.
Thanks, again, Dave.
PLEASE NOTE: This forum is for dialog between Edge of Sports readers. Discuss!
Dave Zirin is the author of the book: "Welcome to the Terrordome: The Pain, Politics and Promise of Sports" (Haymarket). You can receive his column Edge of Sports, every week by
going to dave@edgeofsports.com.
Contact him at edgeofsports@gmail.com